Of the 11 card shops we list in Madison, 4 carry Magic: The Gathering cards. Of those, 4 also carry Pokémon, 4 also carry sports cards, 4 also carry Yu-Gi-Oh. The best-rated is Gamer's Library (★ 4.8 from 407 Google reviews). 4 are open on Sundays. Each listing shows today's hours, phone number and directions; stock changes fast, so call ahead if you're after a specific set or card.
Best-rated Magic: The Gathering stores in Madison
Ranked by Google rating, weighted by number of reviews, so a shop with three perfect reviews can't outrank one with hundreds. Shops with fewer than 10 reviews aren't ranked. Ratings from Google Maps.
All 4 Magic: The Gathering stores in Madison
Misty Mountain Games
Gamer's Library
Mox Mania, LLC
Pegasus Games
More card shops in Madison
Magic: The Gathering Stores in other Wisconsin cities
Frequently asked questions
How many Magic: The Gathering stores are in Madison?
We list 4 card shops in Madison, Wisconsin that carry Magic: The Gathering cards, out of 11 card shops in the city.
What is the best-rated Magic: The Gathering store in Madison?
Gamer's Library has the strongest Google rating among Madison's Magic: The Gathering stores: 4.8 stars from 407 reviews.
Are any Magic: The Gathering stores in Madison open on Sunday?
Yes. 4 of the 4 Magic: The Gathering stores in Madison list Sunday hours. Check each listing for today's hours.
Buying or selling cards? Start here
Straight answers to the questions collectors ask most, with numbers you can check.
- What Is the Best Place to Sell Cards Online in 2026?
- Is It Worth Getting My Card Graded?
- I Inherited a Card Collection. What Should I Do First?
- Is This a Fair Price for My Card?
Want all of it in one place? Buying and Selling Cards: The 2026 Guide