Sports Card Shops in Indianapolis, Indiana — 13 Shops
LocalCardShopsNearMe
13 of 25 card shops

Sports Card Shops in Indianapolis, Indiana

13 sports card shops in Indianapolis, IN, including Family Time Games (4.8★). Compare Google ratings, today's hours, phone numbers and directions.

Of the 25 card shops we list in Indianapolis, 13 carry sports cards. Of those, 7 also carry Pokémon, 7 also carry Yu-Gi-Oh, 6 also carry Magic. The best-rated is Family Time Games (★ 4.8 from 827 Google reviews). 10 are open on Sundays. Each listing shows today's hours, phone number and directions; stock changes fast, so call ahead if you're after a specific set or card.

Best-rated sports card shops in Indianapolis

Ranked by Google rating, weighted by number of reviews, so a shop with three perfect reviews can't outrank one with hundreds. Shops with fewer than 10 reviews aren't ranked. Ratings from Google Maps.

  1. Family Time Games★ 4.8 · 827 Google reviews · 8796 Michigan Rd · (317) 429-9817
  2. Game Preserve★ 4.7 · 709 Google reviews · 1551 E Stop 12 Rd · (317) 881-4263
  3. Indy Card Exchange★ 4.7 · 393 Google reviews · 7035 E 96th St Ste p · (317) 254-8681
  4. Paradigm Games★ 4.7 · 136 Google reviews · 2479 N Meridian St · (715) 379-6831
  5. Oldschool Outpost★ 4.7 · 80 Google reviews · 5215 E Thompson Rd · (317) 775-1781

All 13 sports card shops in Indianapolis

Family Time Games

4.8 (827 Google reviews)
8796 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis, IN
(317) 429-9817
Open 7 days a week
PokémonSports cardsYu-Gi-OhTrading cards

Game Preserve

4.7 (709 Google reviews)
1551 E Stop 12 Rd, Indianapolis, IN
(317) 881-4263
Open 7 days a week
PokémonSports cardsYu-Gi-OhTrading cards

Grandmaster Games

4.3 (599 Google reviews)
4200 S East St Ste 20, Indianapolis, IN
(463) 271-0560
Open 7 days a week
PokémonSports cardsYu-Gi-OhTrading cards

Game Time

4.2 (400 Google reviews)
8244 Center Run Dr, Indianapolis, IN
(317) 577-0900
Open 6 days a week
PokémonSports cardsYu-Gi-OhTrading cards

Indy Card Exchange

4.7 (393 Google reviews)
7035 E 96th St Ste p, Indianapolis, IN
(317) 254-8681
Open 6 days a week
PokémonSports cardsYu-Gi-OhTrading cards

Paradigm Games

4.7 (136 Google reviews)
2479 N Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
(715) 379-6831
Open 6 days a week
Sports cardsTrading cardsMagic

Fan Cave

4.4 (125 Google reviews)
4805 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN
(317) 426-4921
Open 6 days a week
PokémonSports cardsYu-Gi-OhTrading cards

Oldschool Outpost

4.7 (80 Google reviews)
5215 E Thompson Rd, Indianapolis, IN
(317) 775-1781
Open 7 days a week
PokémonSports cardsYu-Gi-OhTrading cards

Collectors Paradise

4.5 (71 Google reviews)
5618 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
(317) 357-2291
Open 5 days a week
Sports cardsTrading cards

The Card Depot

4.4 (32 Google reviews)
1083 E Hanna Ave, Indianapolis, IN
(317) 796-7505
Open 6 days a week
Sports cardsTrading cards

CardVault by Tom Brady

4.7 (10 Google reviews)
2 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
(463) 282-3906
Open 7 days a week
Sports cards

Southside Sports Cards

2.3 (3 Google reviews)
3825 S East St, Indianapolis, IN
(317) 649-6866
Open 6 days a week
Sports cards

Collector's Den

3.9 (77 Google reviews)
6214 Carrollton Ave Ste 100, Indianapolis, IN
(317) 636-8229
Open 5 days a week
Sports cardsTrading cards

More card shops in Indianapolis

All 25 card shopsPokémon Card Shops (10)Magic: The Gathering Stores (10)Yu-Gi-Oh Card Shops (9)

Sports Card Shops in other Indiana cities

Fort Wayne (8)Evansville (6)Muncie (3)

Frequently asked questions

How many sports card shops are in Indianapolis?

We list 13 card shops in Indianapolis, Indiana that carry sports cards, out of 25 card shops in the city.

What is the best-rated sports card shop in Indianapolis?

Family Time Games has the strongest Google rating among Indianapolis's sports card shops: 4.8 stars from 827 reviews.

Are any sports card shops in Indianapolis open on Sunday?

Yes. 10 of the 13 sports card shops in Indianapolis list Sunday hours. Check each listing for today's hours.

Buying or selling cards? Start here

Straight answers to the questions collectors ask most, with numbers you can check.

Want all of it in one place? Buying and Selling Cards: The 2026 Guide

Own a card shop?

Get in front of thousands of collectors searching for card shops near them. Standard listings are always free — or boost your visibility with a featured placement.

List your shop free Advertise with us

Collect cards?

Get the hobby news that matters — new releases, big pulls, grading updates, and card shows near you — straight to your inbox, free.