Home › Blog › Does PSA Sell for More Than Other Card Graders?
Does PSA Sell for More Than Other Card Graders?
The short answer
Yes, on most cards. On matched same-grade sales from Card Ladder, a 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan in PSA 9 averaged $17,500 against $10,600 in BGS 9, and a 1989 Upper Deck Griffey in PSA 10 averaged $2,414 against $1,722 in SGC 10. The premium runs about 10 to 75% depending on the card.
It's narrowest on pre-war vintage, where SGC sells close to even, and it's not a law: a BGS 9.5 can outsell a PSA 10 on some modern cards. PSA also graded about 70% of all cards in September 2026, which is most of why the premium exists.
How much more does a PSA card sell for at the same grade?
Here are matched sales, same card and same numeric grade, from a February 2025 comparison built on Card Ladder's three-month averages. The percentages are PSA's premium over the other grader.
| Card and grade | PSA | SGC | BGS | PSA premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan #57, grade 9 | $17,500 (24 sales) | $9,999 (1 sale) | $10,600 (18 sales) | 65% over BGS |
| 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan #57, grade 6 | $4,142 (33) | $3,570 (1) | $3,751 (7) | 10% over BGS, 16% over SGC |
| 1989 Upper Deck Ken Griffey Jr. #1, grade 10 | $2,414 (63) | $1,722 (5) | 40% over SGC | |
| 1989 Upper Deck Ken Griffey Jr. #1, grade 9 | $189 (156) | $159 (37) | 19% over BGS | |
| 1996 Topps Kobe Bryant #138, grade 9 | $121 (222) | $91 (26) | $116 (21) | 4% over BGS, 33% over SGC |
| 1953 Topps Jackie Robinson #1, grade 5 | $2,573 (2) | $2,262 (3) | 14% over SGC | |
| 2001 Topps Chrome Traded Ichiro #T266, grade 9 | $215 (49) | $138 (2) | 56% over BGS |
Two things to read off that table before you draw a conclusion. The sample sizes are lopsided: PSA sells 5 to 60 times more copies of the same card, so the PSA average is solid and the SGC or BGS average often rests on one or two sales. And the premium is not constant. On the Jordan it's 10% at a 6 and 65% at a 9. The higher and more liquid the card, the more the slab brand matters.
An older study of pre-war cards found the same shape from the other end: on T206 Cy Young portraits across grades 2 to 4, PSA and SGC sold "pretty even," while on a 1952 Topps Mantle the PSA premium over SGC was about 2.5% at grade 4 and up, and 30 to 36% at grades 2 and 3. Vintage collectors trust SGC's black slab; modern buyers want the red PSA flip.
Why does PSA sell for more?
Because almost everyone grades there, so almost every buyer prices there. GemRate counted 2.46 million cards graded by PSA in September 2026 against 962,000 by CGC, 50,000 by TAG and 46,000 by SGC, out of 3.52 million (Beckett wasn't in that month's count). That's roughly 70% of the market, and it makes a PSA 10 the default unit of price: it has the most comps, the most buyers, the most liquidity, and a population report everyone checks.
Three things follow from that, and none of them is "PSA grades better":
- Liquidity is worth money. A PSA card sells faster and to a wider pool, and buyers pay for that even when the card inside is identical.
- The 10 is scarcer where it's strictest. BGS runs a 10-point scale with sub-grades and a 9.5 is its gem, so a BGS 9.5 and a PSA 10 are the same tier, not the same label. A BGS 10 (Pristine) and a BGS Black Label are rarer than a PSA 10, which is why a BGS 9.5 Kobe in that table had one $1,900 sale against PSA 10's $736 average. One sale isn't a market, but it shows the ceiling.
- Crossover costs money. Moving a card from an SGC or BGS slab into PSA means cracking, resubmitting and risking a lower grade, so the discount on the other slabs partly reflects that cost.
When should you grade with someone other than PSA?
The premium matters only if it's bigger than what it costs you to get it. Run three checks.
- Is the card pre-war or early vintage? PSA's premium over SGC is small to none there, and many vintage buyers prefer the black slab. For a 1950s baseball card worth under $1,000, SGC is usually the better trade.
- Are you chasing a 10 on a modern card? PSA, because the PSA 10 is what the market prices. If you believe the card is flawless, BGS and a shot at a Black Label is the only upside case, and it's a long shot.
- Does the fee eat the premium? PSA's Value tier reopened October 29, 2026 at $39.99 a card with a $500 declared value cap and a posted 90 to 100 business day estimate; the $59.99 Standard tier carries a $1,000 cap. On a $150 card, a 20% PSA premium is $30, less than the fee difference between a fast tier and a slow one. On a $2,000 card, 20% is $400, and the choice makes itself.
The 2026 Guide's break-even line is a card likely worth about $150 or more in the grade you expect, and the grading-worth-it answer walks through the math and the three free checks (centering, edges, surface) to run before you spend anything.
What about CGC, TAG and the rest?
CGC Cards graded 962,000 cards in September 2026, a record for them, driven by Pokémon and other TCG product, so a CGC 10 Pristine or a CGC 9.5 is a real market on TCG cards and a thin one on sports. TAG, at about 50,000 a month, sells to collectors who want its computer-scored report; its resale premium hasn't been measured the way PSA's has. For an older grader that's no longer active, or a slab from a company you don't recognize, treat the card as raw: the slab adds nothing and some buyers subtract for it.
Whatever the slab, verify the cert number on the grader's website before you buy or price it. A fake slab or a trimmed card is a bigger risk than the wrong grader.
How do you price a card that isn't in a PSA slab?
Price it from sales of the same card in the same slab, not from PSA comps with a discount guessed on top.
- Pull sold comps for that grader and grade. eBay sold listings, 130point and Card Ladder all let you filter by grader. Use the last 90 days.
- If there are fewer than three, use the PSA comp and a discount taken from the table above. Those matched sales put SGC roughly 15 to 40% under PSA on modern cards and close to even on pre-war, and BGS roughly 5 to 20% under at the same numeric grade on the cards with real sample sizes. Treat a BGS 9.5 as the PSA 10 tier. Adjust from any real sales you do find.
- Check the pop. A low population in any slab supports the price; a huge PSA pop and a tiny SGC pop usually means the SGC copies cross over, which caps their price.
- Write the slab in the title when you sell. "SGC 9.5" in the title finds the buyers who want it, and keeps the PSA buyers from feeling tricked.
And remember what a slab is: a grade and an authentication, not a different card. The four-minute price check works on any of them.
Questions people also ask
Do PSA cards sell for more than SGC cards?
Usually, yes. On matched same-grade sales a 1989 Upper Deck Griffey in PSA 10 averaged $2,414 against $1,722 in SGC 10, a 40% premium, and a 1996 Topps Kobe in grade 9 was 33% higher in PSA. On pre-war vintage the gap is small or zero.
Do PSA cards sell for more than BGS cards?
At the same numeric grade, usually: 65% higher on a 1986 Fleer Jordan at grade 9 and 19% on a 1989 Griffey at grade 9. But BGS's gem is a 9.5, so compare a BGS 9.5 with a PSA 10, and a rare BGS 10 or Black Label can outsell a PSA 10.
What share of cards does PSA grade?
About 70%. GemRate counted 2.46 million PSA grades in September 2026 against 962,000 for CGC, 50,000 for TAG and 46,000 for SGC, out of 3.52 million with Beckett not included that month.
Is SGC better than PSA for vintage cards?
For pre-war and early vintage, the PSA price premium over SGC is small, about 2.5% on a 1952 Topps Mantle at grade 4 and up. Many vintage collectors prefer the black slab, so SGC is a reasonable choice under about $1,000.
How much does PSA grading cost right now?
PSA's Value tier reopened October 29, 2026 at $39.99 a card with a $500 declared value cap and a 90 to 100 business day estimate; the Standard tier is $59.99 with a $1,000 cap. Prices and turnaround change often, so check PSA's site before you submit.
Keep reading
More answers
- Sports Illustrated Collectibles: how much PSA graded cards sell for compared with other grading services, Card Ladder three-month averages (February 18, 2025)
- All Vintage Cards: do PSA graded cards sell for a premium vs SGC and Beckett (updated December 23, 2025)
- CardGrade.io summary of GemRate's September 2026 grading recap (published October 1, 2026)
- GemRate: September 2026 grading recap
- PSA Value tier reopening at $39.99, October 29, 2026 (and Standard at $59.99 as of October 7, 2026)
- PSA: submission updates and current service levels
- Grader comparison, break-even table and the raw-card price check: Buying and Selling Cards: The 2026 Guide, Grading: PSA and the Field, and the Grader Comparison Chart (research verified July to August 2026)